An open source compendium of comments on the Draft SGEIS.
UPCOMING EVENTS
Hydro-Fracking Day of Action
Monday January 23,
11 AM Rally
1– 4 PM Meet with legislators
Legislative Office Building
Albany, New York Register now for visits with legislators.
For details and information on transportation click here.
What do You Know About Hydraulic Fracturing?
Catskill Citizens has prepared a brochure for people who’ve never heard of fracking. It has already been sent to every household in Delaware, Sullivan and Ulster counties. If you’d like to partner with us in sending this to residents in other counties, contact [email protected]
An Integrative Workshop for the Evaluation of the State of Science and Policy. 1 hour 12 minute video of Duke U. workshop. Jan 11, 2012 loaded on YouTube.
Open Space Institute/Urban Design Research Seminar, Graduate School of Architecture Planning and Preservation, Columbia University. Advance exerpt from “Half Full? Water Futures in the Western Catskills” Posted Dec. 1, 2011
Economist Jannette Barth, Ph.D. calls on the DEC to extend the public comment period on the Draft SGEIS so New Yorkers have an opportunity to review the revised socioeconmic study that is now underway.
American Lung Assoc., American Public Health Assoc., American Thoracic Society, Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America, Trust for America’s Health Dated Nov 30, 2011
The US state of New York is considering whether to go ahead with a controversial form of gas drilling.
Al Jazeera’s Kristen Saloomey reports from New York’s Otsego County. Uploaded by AlJazeeraEnglish. 6 minutes video
NY1 VIDEO: Inside City Hall’s Errol Louis discusses the issue of hydrofracking in New York with two supporters of the drilling—Arthur “Jerry” Kremer, a former state assemblyman who is with the New York Affordable Reliable Electricity Alliance, and Ross Pepe, president of the Construction Industry Council and Building Contractors Association—and two opponents: ecologist and author Sandra Steingraber and economist Jannette Barth of J.M. Barth and Associates.
Sept, 2011 Report by Karen Cambpell and Matt Horne from Pembina Institute, a national non-profit think tank that advances sustainable energy solutions. 32 pages
1 hour presentation from an organic farmer in western PA assembles the case for a moratorium on unconventiaonal drilling for natural gas in the Marcellus Shale. Posted Dec. 5, 2011.
Calendar 2010 Reports for: Adirondacks, Capital-Saratoga, Catskills, Central NY, Chautauqua-Allegheny, Finger Lakes, Great Niagara, Hudson Valley, Long Island, New York City, and Thousand Islands by Oxford Economics Company
Amanda L. Weinstein and Dr. Mark D. Partridge (Dept of Agricultural, Environmental and Development Economics of Ohio State U.) 38 page report dated Dec, 2011
Written Public Comments on Hydraulic Fracturing Received by the Secretary of Energy Advisory Board Subcommittee on Natural Gas published 7/21/2022 15 pages
“There is no question that exclusion of industrial uses is a proper and legitimate use of land-use laws.” By David Slottje, Esq.and Helen Holden Slottje , Esq., 2009.
The fossil fuel industry has left out a few details in their informational video about the process of drilling for natural gas. Comedian Julianna Forlano fills in the gaps in this special edition of The Ironic News Report. Oct 8, 2011 7 minute video
Sept 8, 2011 posted video from Berry Tales Excerpt Vol 3. 7:57 minute “Berry Tales” are real, first-hand accounts of how residents of Gardendale, TX have been treated by Berry Oil and their ‘landman’ representative, Gray Surface Specialties. This segment was excerpted…
WellWatch is a web site that allows citizens to better cope with natural gas facilities on their properties or in their communities. It allows them to find out information about companies or wells, and to record notes or complaints about facilities and enter them into the public record.
EPA Tip Line
Report suspicious drilling activities to the EPA
If you see suspicious activity, such as possibly unauthorized water withdrawals, illegal wastewater dumping, or other questionable activity, call the EPA’s Eyes on Drilling line at 1-877-919-4372 (toll free), or send a message to [email protected].
If an emergency is observed related to a well drilling operation, call the National Response Center at 1-800-424-8802.
Tell President Barack Obama how you feel about federal exemptions from the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act and the Safe Drinking Water Act for gas drilling companies.
Catskill Citizens for Safe Energy is an all volunteer grassroots organization working to prohibit dangerous hydraulic fracturing (fracking) since 2008.
10,396! That is the number of public comment letters we submitted to the DEC on your behalf. Heartfelt thanks to all of you who helped with this effort.
Catskill Citizens members, from left to right, Carolyn Duke, Jill Wiener, Ann Finneran, Laurie McFadden, Roy Tedoff and Bruce Ferguson. Photograph by Dana Duke.
2011 and 2012
By any measure, 2011 was a year of real progress in New York State. The tireless works of thousands of fractivists resulted in an unprecedented degree of public awareness and vastly expanded news coverage. A recent Time Magazine article hailed Tony Ingraffea, Bob Howarth and Mark Ruffalo as “People Who Mattered”, and called fracking the “biggest environmental issue” of the year.
Meanwhile, the industry’s multimillion dollar ad campaign to sell fracking to New Yorkers is going nowhere. Statewide polls continue to show that most people who become aware of fracking oppose it, and regional polls demonstrate that there is overwhelming opposition in the communities that sit atop the shale. Town after town has enacted zoning prohibitions and moratoriums that will prohibit fracking.
As the statewide anti-fracking movement enters its fifth year, Catskill Citizens has set its sights on three critical goals.
Protect and Build on Gains at the Local Level
Block State Funding for Fracking
Build Support for a Permanent Ban
Support Home Rule
Map by Karen Edelstein
The move to enact local prohibitions against fracking was a major success story in 2011. More than a dozen towns have already banned fracking, dozens more have enacted moratoriums, and many more are considering similar actions. Expanding on, and protecting, these gains must be one of our top priorities in 2012.
While most lawyers agree that municipalities have the right to zone out fracking, the law is vague – vague enough for the gas industry to try to overturn local ordinances in court. Two towns (Dryden and Middlefield) are already being sued, and the fear of lawsuits prevents many other towns from taking action.
We expect New York’s highest court will eventually uphold the rights of towns to zone out fracking, but it would be a serious setback if unfavorable lower court decisions overturned the zoning prohibitions already in place and halted the rapidly expanding effort to ban drilling at the local level. Areas now off limits would be reopened to fracking, the movement would be disheartened, and the activists who persuaded their communities to enact ordinances would be discredited. We cannot afford to let this happen.
Fortunately there’s a bill in the legislature that clarifies the right to zone out fracking – and it appears to have enough Republican and Democratic support to be enacted. “Home rule” is guaranteed by the state constitution, and the concept has broad appeal across the ideological spectrum; even Governor Cuomo may be loath to force fracking on communities that have acted out of a concern for public safety and to preserve the character of their towns.
The Budget Option: No way around it, fracking will cost New York taxpayers millions in upfront costs. It’s estimated that the DEC itself will need $20 million to begin to ramp up for shale gas extraction, and the Department of Transportation estimates road and bridge repair could cost taxpayers almost $400 million a year.
So what would happen if the legislature simply refused to fund fracking? This intriguing plan was outlined by Sierra Atlantic’s Roger Downs in testimony before a legislative committee last fall. The beauty of a “budget ban” is that is it can be accomplished without the cooperation of either Governor Cuomo or the Republican-controlled Senate. The (somewhat) more progressive Assembly can singlehandedly block fracking by refusing to pass a budget that includes the funds the state will need for fracking.
What about a Legislative Prohibition? While we’d all loved to see an immediate permanent prohibition on fracking in New York State (and elsewhere), we don’t think one can be enacted in the short-term. To get a ban bill through the Senate, it will have to have Republican support that has yet to materialize.
But the current de facto moratorium may give us the time we need to build support for a legislative ban. In recent weeks DEC Commissioner Joe Martens made conflicting statements about when his department will be able to issue permits for high-volume fracking. First he suggested it wouldn’t be able to move ahead in 2012, but more recently he said permitting could begin in “late spring”. Given the fact that the department is legally obligated to read and address the still uncounted tens of thousands of public comments it will receive on the Draft SGEIS, we consider the late spring estimate unrealistic – we think procedural delays are likely to hold up fracking throughout next year.
That means we may have time to build popular support for a ban. While public awareness is growing every day, millions of New Yorkers still haven’t heard a thing about fracking, and we have to change that – we can’t expect our politicians to stand up to the gas industry until the majority of New Yorkers demand they do so.
Save the date! January 23rd will be a statewide day of action. Citizens from across the state will be gathering in Albany to rally and meet with our legislators. For details on transportation, and to sign up to speak with lawmakers, click here.
EXTEND THE PUBLIC COMMENT PERIOD
"The public is entitled to read, and comment on, a complete and competent socioeconomic report - even if that means that the DEC must extend the
public comment period on the revised Draft SGEIS (Draft SGEIS)."
That was economist Jannette Barth responding to reports that NYS DEC Commissioner Joe Martens publicly criticized the socioeconomic portion of the revised Draft
Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement prepared by the outside consulting firm, Ecology & Environment, and called for portions of it to be
rewritten. Commissioner Martens called E&E;'s work "a little thin" and ordered the firm to improve its analysis of issues such as housing and
emergency response.
Dr. Barth also said E&E; may not be qualified to do a proper job, and that "a comprehensive economic assessment would be an expensive research
endeavor and would require a team of qualified experts, each with specific expertise."
With the public comment period on the Draft due to end on January 11th it's not clear how, or even if, the public will have an opportunity to review
E&E;'s revised report.
Dr. Barth called for an extended public comment period in a letter she sent to Commissioner Martens on behalf of Catskill Citizens for Safe Energy, a
volunteer, grassroots organization of which she is a member. The letter was cosigned by more than one hundred others, including State Senator Liz
Krueger, Assembly Members Robert J. Castelli and Barbara Lifton, and representatives of more than sixty non-governmental organizations. Also
signing on were Cornell University economists Edward C. Kokkelenberg, Ph.D. and Timothy Mount, Ph.D. who recently joined Dr. Barth in writing to
Governor Cuomo about the serious deficiencies in the E&E; report.
Tell the Cuomo Administration to stop trying to push fracking down the throats of rural New Yorkers. It’s time to withdraw the Draft SGEIS and prohibit high-volume hydraulic fracturing.
MORAVIA — Nothing seems to draw a town together like hydrofracking. And with nearly 200 people present at its Wednesday event, Moravia’s town forum on fracking was no exception.
Before the 7 p.m. meeting started, cars crowded into the Moravia Volunteer Fire Company’s parking lot, filling every g… [Full Story]
ALBANY, N.Y. — Ignoring taunts from anti-hydrofracking protestors marching outside, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo delivered a nearly hour-long State of the State address to lawmakers Jan. 4 without mentioning the hot-button gas drilling technique.
In his speech, the governor skipped over a section o… [Full Story]
Dear Commissioner Martens:
The American Lung Association in New York is pleased to offer comments on the Revised Draft of the Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement On The Oil, Gas and Solution Mining Regulatory Program in New York (dSGEIS). We urge the New York State Department of Env… [Full Story]
As if the recent series of hearings and the invitation for written comments from the public were not enough, contingents from both sides of the fracking issue in New York State organized rallies and press conferences this week in anticipation of the close of the comment period on the state’s propose… [Full Story]
ALBANY — A top gas-industry trade group and environmental lobbyists on Wednesday offered biting criticism of the state’s review of hydraulic fracturing, as a four-month public comment period came to a close at midnight.
The Department of Environmental Conservation was bombarded Wednesday with hu… [Full Story]
Steelers safety Troy Polamalu recently learned what we here at StateImpact have known for a long time: the issue of natural gas drilling sparks passionate debate.
The Post-Gazette recounts what happened last month, when Polamalu listed the anti-fracking documentary “Gasland” as one of … [Full Story]
Seven people, including government officials, have been charged with corruption during the granting of licenses for shale gas exploration in Poland, a spokesman for prosecutors said Wednesday.
Waldemar Tyl of the Warsaw Appeals Prosecutor’s Office, who announced the charges, said bribes of tens o… [Full Story]
As news outlets across America take a more rigorous look at shale gas and fracking issues, it’s encouraging to see how the media coverage is finally starting to cut through the oil industry’s misleading rhetoric to explore the realities of the myth of gas as a viable ‘bridge fuel.’
The gas indust… [Full Story]
IN 1872, President Ulysses S. Grant signed a mining law to spur the development of the West by giving hard-rock mining precedence over other uses of federal land. But the law has long since outlived its purpose, and its environmental consequences have been severe.
Mining claims for copper, gold, … [Full Story]
As regulators and environmentalists study whether hydraulic fracturing can damage the environment, industry scientists are studying ways to create longer, deeper cracks in the earth to release more oil and natural gas.
Energy companies are focused on boosting production and lowering costs associ… [Full Story]
EXPOSURE to gas drilling operations is strongly linked to serious health problems in humans, pets, livestock and other animals, a new US study has found.
Australian environmentalists say the study shows the need for caution in opening the country up to coal seam gas (CSG) extraction.
Unive… [Full Story]
With a deadline looming this week for the public to weigh in on gas drilling in New York State, the antifracking movement itself has become divided over what its goal should be: securing the nation’s toughest regulations, or winning an outright ban?
The question is pitting brand-name organizatio… [Full Story]
ARLINGTON, Virginia (Reuters) – The public health effects of shale gas development need to be rigorously studied as production rapidly spreads in the United States, public health professionals and advocates said on Monday.
Advances in the hydraulic fracturing, or fracking, drilling technique have… [Full Story]
Drilling could start as soon as this spring in New York State. Wednesday, January 11 is the deadline for public comments to the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) on the draft of the SGEIS that would provide the guidelines for industrial gas drilling and fracking throughout the state. Dr… [Full Story]
WASHINGTON – January 10 – Catskill Mountainkeeper, Delaware Riverkeeper Network, Earthjustice, Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC), and Riverkeeper, Inc. announced today that, after extensive evaluation and technical expert review, they have concluded that the state must go back and revisit sig… [Full Story]
Federal regulators have only a “rudimentary” understanding of the facts and history of gas drilling’s impact on water supplies in Dimock Twp., Pennsylvania’s head environmental regulator wrote in a letter Thursday as the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency considered beginning its own sampling of… [Full Story]
Dimock, Pennsylvania residents may be on the least fun roller-coaster ride ever.
For nearly three years, 11 families with tainted water wells in the small town received daily deliveries of bulk and bottled water from Cabot Oil & Gas Corp.
The natural gas company began arranging for the water… [Full Story]
Troy Polamalu learned last month that there are topics even more controversial than the defense’s performance in Sunday night’s playoff game against the Denver Broncos.
The Steelers strong safety maintains a popular Twitter and Facebook account that sends out movie recommendations every week, i… [Full Story]
This past August methane was found in three private water wells in Lenox Township, located about 10 miles east of Dimock, PA. Investigators from the PA Department of Environmental Protection determined that the gas migrated from a flawed well drilled by Cabot Oil and Gas Corp.
Local news repo… [Full Story]
Objectives: We review the extent to which advisory committees formed in 2011 by the US Department of Energy and the states of Maryland and Pennsylvania contain individuals with expertise pertinent to human environmental public health. We also analyze the extent to which human health issues are of co… [Full Story]
Congressman Lists 10 Problems with Regulations
Washington, DC – Congressman Maurice Hinchey (D-NY) today urged Governor Andrew Cuomo to withdraw the revised draft Supplemental Generic Environmental Impact Statement (dSGEIS) on high-volume horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing in the Marcel… [Full Story]
Jan. 9 (Bloomberg) — The U.S. should declare a moratorium on hydraulic fracturing for natural gas in populated areas until the health effects are better understood, doctors said at a conference on the drilling process.
Gas producers should set up a foundation to finance studies on fracking and i… [Full Story]
If anyone in the General Assembly listened to the scientists at the hydraulic fracturing workshop at Duke University today, then any pro-fracking legislation should be dead in North Carolina. That’s not a given: Last week, the GOP-led majority threatened a midnight override to Gov. Perdue’s veto of … [Full Story]
Recently-graduated SUNY Geneseo geography major Ben Wunder’s interest in hydrofracking can probably be attributed to a gas well behind his Owego home.
Horizontal drilling was undertaken there, although this was not a hydrofracking well and did not penetrate the Marcellus shale layer.
Still, th… [Full Story]
A broad coalition of more than 50 environmental, faith, labor, student and consumer organizations representing hundreds of thousands of New Jersey residents renewed their call for a ban on fracking in New Jersey by submitting a letter to New Jersey Senate President Stephen M. Sweeney asking him to h… [Full Story]
Treasure the Karoo Action Group will apply to the Pretoria High Court today for an order compelling Mineral Resources Minister Susan Shabangu to reveal more about the team she set up last year to assess hydraulic fracturing (“fracking”).
Save & Share
Email
Print
… [Full Story]
Corning, N.Y. —
The state Department of Environ-mental Conservation has received 18,100 written comments so far on the latest draft of its new regulations for shale gas drilling, DEC spokeswoman Emily DeSantis said Thursday.
The comment period began in early September and will close Wednes… [Full Story]
WASHINGTON – Congressman Maurice Hinchey Monday urged Governor Cuomo to withdraw the revised draft supplemental generic environmental impact statement on hydro-fracking in the Marcellus Shale and other areas in the state.
Hinchey, like many environmental groups, believes the document does not go … [Full Story]
The U.S. should declare a moratorium on hydraulic fracturing (aka “fracking”) of natural gas in populated areas until the health effects are better understood, doctors said at a conference on the well-completion process used to stimulate natural gas and oil production.
[Full Story]
EnCana Oil & Gas USA has asked the Environmental Protection Agency’s Office of Research & Development to “suspend” the current public comment period on EPA Region 8’s “Pavillion Report,” which was released to the public on December 8 and implicated hydraulic fracturing as a likely contributor to con… [Full Story]
On Jan. 10 at 1 p.m. on the west lawn of the Ohio Statehouse in Columbus, Ohio, concerned citizens from all over the state will gather to ask Gov. Kasich to impose an indefinite moratorium on Ohio’s oil and gas wastewater injection well sites and the natural gas extraction process that has become we… [Full Story]
Derry’s Nerve Centre will screen a free showing of the Sundance award-winning documentary film ‘Gasland’ this coming Thursday, January 12, at 7pm.
The film, which won the 2010 Sundance Film Festival Special Jury Prize, explores the culture of “fracking”, which has become a growing concern in Ir… [Full Story]
Geological experts say earthquakes in Ohio and Oklahoma are directly tied to deep wells used to dispose of liquid wastes for hydraulic fracturing, also known as fracking, of natural gas. The experts also said they expect more earthquakes to occur as drilling expands across the U.S., according to MSN… [Full Story]
Methane in three private water wells in Lenox Twp. seeped there from a flawed natural gas well drilled by Cabot Oil & Gas Corp., state environmental regulators have found.
An investigation by the Department of Environmental Protection determined that the gas migrated from at least one of three M… [Full Story]
EPA in Court
Landowner rights and government power are in the docket Monday. The U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments in Sackett v. Environmental Protection Agency, a case that stems from an EPA determination that an Idaho couple was building their home in a wetland. The agency ordered the Sacke… [Full Story]
PITTSBURGH (AP) – Pennsylvania’s Department of Environmental Protection undercounted the number of wells producing gas from the Marcellus Shale, frustrating industry, environmental groups, and elected officials, according to a newspaper report.
The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette reported that an analysi… [Full Story]
Industry Called Upon to Set Up Foundation to Conduct Needed, Independent Research
WASHINGTON, D.C. – January 9, 2012 – Leading U.S. medical experts urged today that the rapid expansion of unconventional natural gas drilling (known as “hydro fracking”) for natural gas extraction be paused so … [Full Story]
A spokesman for the Environmental Protection Agency tells WHYY’s Newsworks the EPA has “not made a decision” on whether or not to deliver water to residents of Dimock, Susquehanna County, whose water wells have been impacted by methane migration.
“We’re evaluating next steps includi… [Full Story]
Surging prices for oil and natural- gas shales, in at least one case rising 10-fold in five weeks, are raising concern of a bubble as valuations of drilling acreage approach the peak set before the collapse of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc.
Chinese, French and Japanese energy explorers committed … [Full Story]
Methane in three private water wells in Lenox Township seeped there from a flawed natural gas well drilled by Cabot Oil and Gas Corp., state environmental regulators have found.
An investigation by the Department of Environmental Protection determined that the gas migrated from at least one of th… [Full Story]
To what should be the surprise of no one, earthquakes caused by the junkie gas sector’s hydraulic fracturing process, known as fracking, have been cropping up like Freud’s repressed. The latest ominously arrived in Republican-dominated Ohio on New Year’s Eve, quickly prompting Youngstown’s mayor to … [Full Story]
A year ago, an executive from Bridge Resources Corp. said that in 2011 natural gas could be flowing from its wells into the Williams Pipeline.
This week, the company that discovered commercial quantities of natural gas in Idaho is expected to sell off its assets near New Plymouth — and that gas i… [Full Story]